Book Review: The Highwayman Piney by Tony DiGerolamo (The Pineys Book 6)

 Genre: Paranormal Thriller / Supernatural Horror

Tropes: Resurrection Villain, Revolutionary War Ghost, Demon Gates, Family Legacy, Found Family, Ongoing Rivalry, Small-Town Supernatural

Spice Level: None

Format: eBook

Series: The Pineys (Best read in order)

    Bloody John Bacon is back from the dead—since Hemmingway’s previous trap didn’t hold. Determined to rip open the gates of hell and free his brother, Bacon won’t let anyone stand in his way. Unfortunately for him, the Galloways have other plans. First comes revenge for Hem trapping him for decades. Then unleashing apocalypse-level chaos. The question is—who wins this round?

    I received a copy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.

    I’ve read every Pineys installment leading up to this one and have consistently enjoyed the series. The foundation remains familiar—supernatural threats, family dynamics, high-stakes confrontations—but each book introduces a fresh twist. This time, the enemy is a Revolutionary War–era pirate and British loyalist with the ability to summon followers—dead or alive—to fight for the crown.

    That historical paranormal element adds a fun layer to the horror.

    I especially enjoyed the pacing in this installment, along with the introduction of yet another long-lost family member. It gave the story added emotional depth. The ongoing tension between Hemmingway and his ex-wife also continues to evolve, and I’m genuinely rooting for them this time. Knowing more of the truth might finally allow both of them to move forward.

⚠️ Reading Order Note:

    While technically these books could be read out of order, I strongly recommend starting from Book 1. The interpersonal relationships, grudges, and character development matter. Hemmingway, in particular, takes time to grow on you, and without earlier context, he may not be immediately likable.

    This is another solid addition to a consistently entertaining paranormal series with historical horror elements and strong family-centered stakes.

                This book is available on Kindle Unlimited or buy it on Amazon for $2.99 by clicking here.

⭐ You’ll love this book if you enjoy:

• Supernatural thrillers with historical villains
• Ongoing family sagas
• Small-town paranormal chaos
• Ghosts, demons, and resurrection plots
• Action-heavy paranormal series

Books by this author: 

My Cousin, The Piney (The Pineys Book 1)

Witch Piney are You (The Pineys Book 2)

Third Grade Piney (The Pineys Book 3)

Feud of the Pineys (The Pineys Book 4)

Jersey Shore Piney (The Pineys Book 5)